c/dish-soap-deep-dive

My trusty pump dispenser gave up mid-suds on a Tuesday night

I was scrubbing a week of baked lasagna off my favorite casserole dish when the pump on my usual bottle just stopped pushing soap. It wasn't the brand's fault, the spring mechanism inside finally snapped after 8 months of daily use. I dumped the remaining soap into a spare squirt bottle I keep under the sink, which worked fine but made me realize I rely too much on fancy dispensers. Has anyone else had a pump fail on them, or am I the only one who sticks with the classic squeeze bottle?

0 comments

the_abby•9d ago

Three month quest for a scent that didn't smell like a candle store

I thought I was done after trying the lavender one from the grocery store, but then my hands felt like sandpaper by Tuesday. So I went on this whole hunt through five different stores in Portland trying every citrus and herb option I could find. The winner ended up being a tiny bottle from a farmers market stall that costs 7 dollars and smells like actual lemons and thyme, not fake lemon candy. My hands still dry out a bit but it's nowhere near as bad as the big name brands. Has anyone else found that the smaller makers just get the scent balance right without wrecking your skin?

0 comments

the_patricia•10d ago

My sister swore by lemon dish soap, she was so wrong

My sister Jenna told me to ditch my usual stuff for a lemon scented bottle she got on sale at the Piggly Wiggly in Greenville. Within 3 days my hands were cracked like crazy and the smell made me gag every time I opened the sink. I went back to my trusty clear unscented brand and it cleared up in a week. Anyone else had a bad reaction to those citrus ones, or is it just me?

1 comments

the_nina•12d ago

The vinegar soak trick that finally killed the grease film on my glasses

I was about to toss a $60 pair of reading glasses. Every dish soap I tried left that cloudy film after a week. Dawn, Palmolive, even the fancy eco stuff. Nada. Then my neighbor said try a 50/50 white vinegar and warm water soak for 10 minutes. Did it last Tuesday. Film gone. Smeared less than the day I bought them. Anyone else had luck with this or is there a better hack I'm missing?

1 comments

lucas_carr24•12d ago

Why does the pump bottle always fail right when your hands are full of suds?

Last Tuesday I was deep in a mountain of greasy pans after a big chili cook-off, and my dish soap pump just gave up. You know the drill, you push and push and nothing comes out, so you end up shaking the bottle upside down and getting a glob of soap straight to the floor. I had two options that night: keep wrestling with the half-dead pump or dump the whole bottle into a squeeze bottle I had lying around. The squeeze bottle won, and honestly it made the whole cleanup 10x faster, but now I'm wondering if I've been on the wrong side of this debate for years. Some folks swear pump bottles keep the soap thicker and last longer, but I feel like squeeze bottles give you full control and zero clog dramas. Has anyone else made the switch mid-cleanup, or do you stick with the pump no matter how many times it leaves you stranded with a sink full of grease?

1 comments

jana_lewis16•13d ago

One horrible Sunday with that lemon-scented store brand

Last weekend I washed a whole greasy lasagna pan and that cheap lemon soap left this weird film on everything, plus my hands felt like sandpaper for hours. I normally grab whatever's on sale, but this time I'm wondering if spending a few extra bucks on something with aloe is worth it. Anyone else have a brand that just wrecked a dish day for them?

1 comments

charliew99•14d ago

My aunt swore vinegar cuts grease better than any soap, but my pans came out sticky after 2 weeks of trying it

She told me to skip the fancy stuff and just use straight white vinegar for everything, but now I've got this weird film on my cast iron and I'm wondering if anyone else got burned by that home remedy or if I just did it wrong somehow?

1 comments

the_abby•18d ago

Pump foam dispenser finally gave up after 8 months of nightly scrubbing

The plastic collar cracked on Tuesday mid-wash and a stream of soap shot straight across my kitchen counter in Spokane, so I scooped the last of the liquid into an old jam jar and now I'm wondering if anyone else has found a refillable bottle that actually lasts more than a year without leaking?

1 comments

kaiharris•19d ago

Spent $14 on a "premium" lemon soap, hands still feel like sandpaper

Bought that fancy castile-based lemon dish soap everyone raves about. It smells nice for about 30 seconds, then my knuckles crack like a bad sidewalk. The $2 store brand with the gross green dye leaves my hands softer, go figure. Anyone else paying extra for worse skin?

1 comments

rowan_kelly64•19d ago

Left a sample bottle at a friend's place, now I can't go back

I brought my favorite lemon-scented dish soap to a potluck last month to help with cleanup, and somehow the bottle stayed there until this weekend. When I finally got it back, I realized washing her dishes with her cheap generic brand felt totally different, like the suds just vanished and my hands turned into sandpaper. Has anyone else accidentally upgraded their standards like this, or am I stuck being picky about dish soap forever now?

1 comments

daniel_martinez92•20d ago

Hit 500 bottles washed with the same dollar store sponge

I kept a tally on my fridge for the last 4 months, every plate and cup I scrubbed with one of those 3-for-a-dollar scrubbers. It finally hit 500 last night and the sponge still has most of its shape, just a bit softer on the edges. Anyone else track how long their scrubbers last, or am I the only one with a weird count going?

1 comments

terryrobinson•21d ago

Hit 500 bottles washed with the same pump bottle of soap, still amazed

Bought a big refill jug of that lemon stuff back in March and filled up my old pump bottle. Just counted the refills in my head, 500 dishes? Maybe more, I lost track after week 3. The pump still works like day one, no clogging or sticking. That got me thinking, we all talk about which soap cuts grease best, but nobody mentions the pump lasting. My last cheap brand died at like 200 uses, handle snapped clean off. This one's going strong, so I'm curious, has anyone else actually tracked how long their bottle lasts before the pump gives up?

2 comments

stella_roberts•24d ago

The scent festival at my sink turned into a regret fest

Last Saturday I grabbed four different dish soaps from the clearance rack to compare, thinking I was about to have a fun kitchen experiment. Turns out mixing lemon, lavender, and two floral scents makes my whole apartment smell like a spilled perfume counter had a fight with a citrus grove. My hands are red and cracked from swapping between them all afternoon, and the smell still hasn't faded even after washing everything twice. How do you guys actually test multiple soaps without turning your sink into a sensory nightmare, or do you just pick one and commit?

1 comments

gray_smith67•27d ago

Dawn is overrated and I'll die on that hill

A friend told me I was crazy for using the store brand stuff, so I tried Dawn for a week and my hands cracked so bad I couldn't grip a chainsaw. Went right back to the $2 bottle from Aldi - anyone else find the expensive stuff just isn't worth it?

2 comments

tessa_rivera•28d ago

Finally figured out why my hands were cracking so bad after doing dishes

I've been washing dishes for years and always blamed the hot water for my dry hands. Last month I ran out of my usual soap and grabbed a bottle of that cheap lemon stuff from the dollar store. After two days my knuckles were bleeding and I couldn't figure out why. Turns out I never looked at the ingredients before, but that cheap soap had way more alcohol and sulfates in it. My regular brand (Dawn) uses milder stuff, but the dollar store one stripped every bit of oil off my skin. Has anyone else had a random brand mess up their hands like that out of nowhere?

1 comments

joseph_martinez35•29d ago

Debate: Is the new lemon verbena dish soap worth the hype or is it just overpriced water?

I grabbed a bottle of that new lemon verbena stuff last week at the Target on Main Street because everyone in this group was raving about it. Three years ago I would have just stuck with my usual Dawn, but after trying cheap brands that dried out my hands like crazy I wanted something different. My only problem is it costs $5.50 a bottle and I swear it cuts grease worse than the dollar store brand I used back in March. For those who've tested it for a month or more, does it actually hold up or is the scent the only thing going for it?

1 comments

charlie37•1mo ago

That expensive lemon verbena dish soap was a total bust

I spent $14 on a bottle of that fancy soap last month and it left my hands feeling like sandpaper after three days. Has anyone else had a fancy soap completely wreck their skin like that?

2 comments

barbara_butler•1mo ago

I dropped $30 on a fancy lemon verbena dish soap and it smelled like furniture polish

I saw it at a little boutique in Portland last spring and figured hey, why not treat myself. Got it home, washed one plate, and the smell was so strong and fake I almost gagged. It left a weird film on my glasses too. I used it three times and then just threw it out. Has anyone else fallen for a pricey dish soap that turned out to be a total dud?

2 comments

xena_murphy•1mo ago

Grabbed the wrong bottle during a late night sink session and ended up with hand soap on a full load of dinner dishes

I was in my kitchen around 11 PM last Tuesday, half asleep, and pumped the green bottle by the faucet not realizing I'd left my mint-scented hand soap there instead of the Dawn, and now the whole casserole dish and every plate has that weird foamy soap film that won't rinse off, has anyone else done this and found a trick to get the residue gone?

1 comments

uma_mitchell83•1mo ago

Just realized the scent "Fresh Linen" means totally different things to different brands

Was at my sister's place last weekend. She uses this fancy lemon ginger soap. Smells like a kitchen exploded. I asked if she had any "normal" dish soap. She handed me her "Fresh Linen" bottle. Sniffed it and it smelled like a clean t-shirt straight out the dryer. Then I remembered the "Fresh Linen" I bought at the dollar store last month. Smelled like bleach and regret. Not even close to the same thing. How is that even allowed? Anyone else get burned by a scent name that lied to you?

2 comments

angela890•1mo ago

Had to pick between lemon verbena and lavender mint at the store yesterday

I ran out of dish soap mid rinse last night and had to make a late run to the grocery store. They had two new scents on sale, lemon verbena and lavender mint, both same price at $3.49. Usually I grab the plain lemon stuff but thought hey, let's try something. I grabbed the lavender mint because it smelled nice in the bottle. Got home and started washing a greasy lasagna pan and within 2 minutes my hands felt weirdly tingly and smelled like a garden that got attacked by a skunk. The scent was super strong and not in a good way, like someone dumped too much essential oil in there. Now I'm stuck with a big bottle I don't want to use and I'm kicking myself for not going with the lemon verbena. Has anybody else had a scent regret that bad with dish soap?

2 comments

stellablack•1mo ago

Found out my grandma's Dawn from the 80s had way more phosphates than today's stuff

I was looking up old ads on YouTube and stumbled onto a comparison video that said the formula changed in the 90s to be less harsh on the environment. Made me wonder if that's why my hands felt so different washing dishes at her house as a kid. Anyone else notice a big change in how their favorite bottle feels now?

2 comments

leo567•1mo ago

Been using Mrs. Meyer's for 6 months and my hands finally stopped cracking

Everyone I know raves about Dawn but that stuff dries me out so bad. Switched to the lavender Mrs. Meyer's back in April and my knuckles don't bleed anymore. Anyone else have a dish soap that fixed their skin problems?

2 comments

kelly338•1mo ago

Tried that fancy lemon verbena dish soap everyone raves about...

It smelled amazing for about 5 minutes, then my hands started cracking like old leather after just two washes. What cheap soap do you guys use that actually leaves your hands feeling normal?

1 comments

robinson.matthew•1mo ago

Showerthought: That minty dish soap trend from 2018 was the worst thing to happen to my sink.

I swear, all those fancy "natural" mint soaps just leave a weird residue on my plates and now I'm stuck scrubbing twice as long to get it off, has anyone else noticed how they don't cut through grease the way the old lemon stuff did?

2 comments