My $1.25 peanut butter from Dollar Tree separated into oil and paste and I almost cried in the parking lot | Dollar Store Dinners

Matthew Gonzalez · 2026-09-29T05:20:04.423449+00:00

I stirred that jar for 10 minutes in my car outside the store on 5th Ave and it still tasted like sad drywall on my sandwich, so has anyone found a cheap brand that doesn't do this?

The Community Guide

Loading…

My $1.25 peanut butter from Dollar Tree separated into oil and paste and I almost cried in the parking lot | Dollar Store Dinners - The Community Guide