Can we talk about how my $3 garage sale mug beats the $22 one I babied for 2 years?
The expensive mug from that pottery place in Boulder got one tiny hairline crack after 2 years and I stopped using it out of fear, while the cheap 3-dollar one with the big chip on the rim still gets grabbed every single morning. Turns out the chipped one just fits my hand better and holds heat longer, so I retired the fancy one to a shelf. Does anyone else have a cheap mug that outlasted and outperformed the pricey one they felt bad about replacing?
The part about the fancy mug getting "retired to a shelf" after one hairline crack really gets me, because I've done the exact same thing. My question is what actually made you stop trusting it? Was it fear of the crack getting worse and leaking, or was it more about not wanting to mess up something you paid real money for? I keep wondering if the cheap mug wins just because we don't care if it breaks, so we use it harder and it kind of earns its keep. The heat thing makes sense too, since a thick cheap mug holds temp better than some thin pretty one. Do you think you'd ever go back to a pricey mug after this, or are you done paying for looks?