Rant: my buddy in Amarillo says you gotta strip a rusty skillet down to bare metal, and I think that's dead wrong | Cast Iron Comrades - The Community Guide
Man, that reminds me of my uncle's old cast iron that sat in his garage for like a decade. He swore the rust meant it was ruined, but my cousin just scrubbed it with steel wool and bacon grease and it cooked better than ever. Some folks treat rust like a death sentence when it's really just surface stuff most of the time. Your buddy in Amarillo might be overthinking it.