Update: the tape wasn't the problem, my roof joints were backwards
Built a two room fort with my kids last weekend and the roof kept caving in no matter how much tape I used. After 3 failed roof panels and about 90 minutes of fighting it, I finally saw the flaps on one side were folded the wrong way so nothing locked together. Flipping those flaps and cutting small slots to interlock them fixed the whole thing in maybe 5 minutes. Now I want to know if anyone has a trick for holding up a tunnel section without a box underneath, because that's my next battle.