Warning: our club almost split over reading the book in chunks vs all at once, and one way clearly won
Our little book club of 7 here in Columbus tried something different with our last pick. For the first 3 meetings we had everyone finish the whole book before we met, and honestly those talks were a mess. Half the group forgot the early chapters, and the other half kept tipping each other off about the ending without meaning to. So for February we tried reading it in chunks, about 80 pages at a time, and meeting every 10 days to talk just that part. The talks got way better. People actually remembered details, and the new mom in our group could keep up since she read in small bits on her lunch break. One guy still grumbled that he likes to binge a whole book, but even he admitted the talk on chapter 9 was the best one we've had. Now we can't agree on which way to do it for March, so how does your club handle the pace?
Laughed at the image of half your group spoiling the ending by accident, because that would be me. I'm the guy who gets too excited and blurts out stuff without thinking, so chunk reading would save my friends from me. We do chunks too, mostly because two of us have kids and can't read 300 pages in a week without losing sleep. My take is do chunks for the book talk but let the binge readers finish early if they want, long as they keep their mouths shut at meetings. Only rule we'd need is no spoilers past the chunk, and your chapter 9 guy can still read ahead without wrecking it for everyone.