Our book club kept picking 400 page doorstops and quitting by chapter 3, so I capped us at 250 pages
We had six straight months where nobody finished the book. Our pick for March was 420 pages and only two of eight people got past chapter 4, so I brought a rule to the next meeting: nothing over 250 pages for a while. I got eye rolls at first, but we read a 190 page novel in April and every single person finished it. The talk was so much better because we could argue about the ending instead of pretending we read it. We have done four books this way now and attendance is up from four people to seven. I know some folks like the big chunky ones, but I would rather finish a short book together than stall out on a big one. Has anyone else tried capping length in their club, and did it stick or did people get bored of the shorter stuff?