A coworker's take on unreliable narrators made me question my favorite book
I was raving about a thriller we read last month, and this guy from the dish pit, Marcus, told me he thought the narrator was just lying to make herself look better. I laughed it off at first, but then he pointed out three specific scenes where her story didn't add up, like the phone call she claimed she made at 9 PM but the voicemail timestamp said 9:45. That sat with me for a week, and on my second read, I found about five other places where she conveniently forgot details. Now I'm wondering if I've been too trusting of narrators in general, and it kind of ruins the fun. Has anyone else had a book fall apart for them after someone else pointed out a small inconsistency?
Why does a narrator have to be honest for a book to be good? Some of the best stories out there are built on lies, and the lies are the whole point. Think about it: if the phone call time doesn't match, that could be the author clueing you in on purpose, not messing up. Marcus basically did the work of a detective for you, and that should make the book more fun, not less. The narrator hiding stuff is the thriller doing its job. Your first read was one version of the story, your second read is a whole different book, and that is a gift, not a problem.