Why my shop still smells like a garage sometimes from quenching in old oil
My dad showed me how used motor oil can quench medium carbon steel without making it brittle. It leaves a dark finish that resists rust pretty well. I use it for making hardy tools that take a beating. New quenches are faster, but this cheap trick has never failed me.
Seriously, the smell is the least of my worries with old oil. Even with a fan like Karen739 said, the sludge and mess it leaves on everything is just not worth it for me. I switched to proper quench oil just to keep the shop clean.
Well I'll be darned, you're absolutely right about that sludge and mess. That sticky black tar gets into every little gap and crevice, it's a nightmare to scrub off your anvil and tongs. I ran some old motor oil through a quench once and it left this weird sticky film on a blade I was pretty proud of, took forever to polish it off. Proper quench oil might cost a bit more, but it keeps your workspace from looking like a Superfund site and honestly your steel comes out cleaner too.