Unpopular opinion: quench oil temp was ruining my 1084 blades until I tried the kitchen thermometer trick
I've been pulling my hair out for about 5 months on some 1084 hunter blades and could not figure out why some came out hard as glass and others came out soft and buttery. I was sure it was my heat treat, so I rebuilt my whole process twice and still got random results. Then a guy at the monthly hammer-in in Fort Wayne mentioned he keeps a $12 instant read kitchen thermometer in his quench bucket and swears by it. I felt like an idiot but I tried it, and it turns out my oil was sitting around 60 degrees on cold mornings and closer to 130 by noon in my shop, and that swing was the whole problem. Bringing it to a steady 120 made every single blade harden the same way, 3 out of 3 to be exact. I know it sounds too simple but the cheap thermometer beat my guessing by a mile. Anyone else track their quench temp or am I late to this party?