Guy at the hammer-in in Athens said he quenches 5160 in motor oil and I think he is dead wrong
He claimed brine and parks 50 are just for show and that any old oil gets the job done, but I watched his test blade come out of the tank at 130 degrees with a warp you could see from across the lawn, so what temp are you all actually running your quench oil at?
I read somewhere that 5160 actually wants a fast oil, like parks 50 speed, because it needs to get below the pearlite nose quick or you lose hardness. Motor oil is way slower than that and it gets thicker as it heats up, so the guy is basically fighting his own quench the hotter it gets. Also 130 degrees is way too hot, most folks aim for around 120 to 130 for some oils but that's the max, not the target, and warm motor oil is even slower than cold. The warp is probably from uneven cooling more than anything, one side hit the oil different than the other. Dude needs to read a data sheet before he tells people brine and parks are for show.