Update: picked the junkyard alternator over a new one for my 97 Civic, saved $110
My original alternator died on the way to work in Tucson and the parts store wanted $160 for a reman while the pick and pull had a used one for $50. I grabbed the junkyard unit, cleaned the terminals, and it has been charging fine for 3 weeks now. How do you all decide when a used part is worth the risk versus just paying for new?
Used parts are kind of like buying fruit from the discount bin. Sometimes you get a perfectly good banana for a quarter, sometimes it's brown mush by the time you get home. My rule is the part can't be a huge pain to swap twice, so an alternator or a starter is fair game but a water pump on a timing belt car, no way. The risk only makes sense when the job is easy and the savings are big. Three weeks of good charging on a $50 alt sounds like you won this round.