Found a 1737 map in my late uncle's garage that put a town in the wrong state, and I spent a week on it
Cleaning out my late uncle's garage in Tulsa a couple weeks back, I found a framed map from 1737 shoved behind his water heater. The town of "New Chester" sat clearly on the Pennsylvania side of a river line. But every other record I could find puts the real New Chester in Maryland. I spent about four nights on it, checking county histories and two 1800s survey books I borrowed from the library. Turns out the mapmaker copied from an earlier Dutch source with a bad border guess, and the error got reprinted for decades. Anyone run into a made-up town name like this on an old map, and how did you confirm it was wrong?